Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone!

Recently, I’ve been spending a lot of time looking at the Terms of Use pages created by various social media platforms. After the recent controversy surrounding the Pinterest Terms of Use, I thought it might be a good idea to dig deeper into some of these mind-numbingly boring legal documents to see what other nuggets might be hiding amongst the legalese.

One of the more interesting ones that I uncovered was in the Facebook Terms of Use.

Periodically, someone in my Facebook feed will post a link to a Facebook Page about the “Keep Facebook Free Revolution” or “Stop Facebook from charging $4/month“. Until this point, these have all be hoaxes that tend to generate a lot of Likes and Shares, because people want Facebook to be free and get irritated when they hear rumors of Facebook proposing charges.

In fact, Facebook has done a pretty good job of reassuring users that they will continue to be free by posting it on their blog and by posting it clearly on their login page.

In light of becoming a public company, will Facebook have to start charging Developers and Publishers?

Will Facebook always be free for everyone? Their Terms of Use indicates otherwise.

Obviously, the tradeoff to Facebook being free is that they have to monetize the site through Ads. This means ads in your timeline and ads in the right-rail of the site. For the most part, I think users are okay with the ads, as long as they are targeted to their needs and aren’t obtrusive to interacting with Facebook. Up until now, however, Facebook has had the luxury of being a privately-held company, which means they aren’t beholden to the whims and fancies of public investors. With that about to change, I have grown more curious as to how they will handle the pressure from their public investors to generate revenue.

Which leads me to the nugget!

Buried deep in the “Special Provisions Applicable to Developers/Operators of Applications and Websites ” section of their Terms of Use, is a provision that says:

14. We do not guarantee that Platform will always be free.

Wait…what?

I just logged in and the front page of Facebook clearly indicated “It’s free and always will be.” Right?!? Free…always?!?

The disparity between the two likely lies in the target audience. By stating “It’s free and always will be.” on the front page of Facebook, the company is communicating to end-users that they intend to keep Facebook a free resource for general users.

The statement of “We do not guarantee that the Platform will always be free.” is more targeted at the development community, indicating that the ability to build apps that integrate directly into Facebook might come at a charge in the future. While game developers like Zynga (the makers of Farmville) and nearly every brand page out there currently enjoy the Facebook developer platform free of charge, this one line, buried amongst the legalese of the Terms of Use document, clearly indicates that these services could come with a surcharge in the future.

The question is how much, and whether brands and developers would be willing to pay to participate on Facebook. We know that social gaming accounts for a massive amount of time on Facebook, so if developers like Zynga found it more lucrative to publish their games elsewhere due to high charges by Facebook, would it also lead to a bleeding of Facebook users to other platforms? Who knows.

So, with that single provision buried in their Terms of Use, Facebook leaves a lot of questions unanswered:

  • Will Facebook start charging for access to their development platform?
  • If so, when will they start and how much will the charge developers, brands and publishers?
  • If Facebook does start to charge, will the costs drive developers, brands and publishers to other platforms?
  • If the developers, brands and publishers leave will Facebook users leave, as well?

While there hasn’t been any indication by Facebook that they’re going to start to charge developers any time soon, it could be something that we see arise soon after their Initial Public Offering (IPO), when the company becomes more beholden to their shareholders, rather than their users. I guess we’ll find out soon enough…

What we do know is that while Facebook is free for users, developers, companies, and organizations…it has become a huge part of our life, impacting how much time we spend eating, sleeping, and even caring for others. Would charging developers impact that passion? Only time will tell.

Have thoughts or questions? I always love to hear them in comments!

Cheers!

–Sean

Comments And Reactions

  1. great read, i read it all…Have a Rock and Roll Saturday! #14

  2. stevenandre says:

    With the adds i can live..

    • I think everyone has been okay with the ads up to this point. The problems start to arise when Facebook starts to charge developers. Then, to pass the costs along to the users, the developers start to charge for their games, apps, etc…or just fill their games/apps so full of ads that no one wants to use them anymore. Then, users start to get tired of Facebook, they start looking to other free platforms, and the spiral begins….

      A lot of people think that Facebook will be around forever. But ask MySpace how that feels. And when’s the last time you bought something on eBay?

      Just my $.02 ;)

      –Sean

  3. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/KjyfPIHJ via @socmedsean

  4. I’m not against FB charging the developers. It’s similar to charging for ad space. As long as they keep it free for the general users. Brands and companies reaching those huge numbers of users, probably expect to be paying for it. If FB starts charging, then other platforms will charge too. If you can charge, and the market will pay, you charge.

    • The issues arise when those developers, who now have to make up the subscription fees, decide to either pull out of Facebook or start packing their apps so full of ads that they turn off the users.

      If Facebook makes it unpleasant for Developers, then it will likely have a negative impact on both Facebook and its users. Where would FB be now without Farmville and Mafia Wars?

      Thanks for the comment!

      –Sean

  5. Excellent article and an easy read. You have an excellent writing style and an eye for interesting topics.

  6. Once they have outside investors, they will be more apt to start charging to keep shareholders happy. It is the way of the beast, so to speak. If they are able to earn enough from advertisers, they may be able to hold out for a couple of years, but then the shareholders will be asking why there is no increse in their share earnings, and the hammer will fall. How hard is going to be determined on the number of shares Facebook decides to put on the market. The more shares they sell, the harder the hammer will fall. If it falls hard enough, even the users may feel the effects in a minor monthly fee being applied. Only time will tell.

  7. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/qvrDXU73 via @socmedsean

  8. Silly really unless the model chosen for revenue calls for R&D to be drawn back. Freebies may be like @Youtube ads all over the place. Split it off maybe Trackbacks would do the tric and leave Fb alone to those who made what it is – Us the users.
    Thanks Sean

  9. So basically, it’s saying the Platform that a developer runs might not always be free. Facebook will always be free to its users.

  10. Facebook will always be free to its users.

    • It depends on what they classify as a “user”, Jorge. I would argue that page owners, bands, businesses, non-profits, and local governments are just as much “users” of Facebook as individual account holders. If Facebook intends to meet the needs of their investors after going public, they may need to expand their revenues beyond just ads, which might make the development platform the next place to start charging.

      Cheers!

      –Sean

  11. Facebook’s statement to the end user is accurate and (I believe) always will be. As far as developers go, that’s a separate point that doesn’t conflict in the slightest. Will Facebook eventually charge developers who want to produce content for the platform? It’s quite likely. Will that cost be substantial enough to deter continued development? Probably not from any serious developers, as long as Facebook continues to provide access to such a wide and engaged audience. Facebook is a free site, but it generates crazy revenue precisely because of that audience, so any shareholders would have to be morons to push for major changes to the company’s successful mode of operation. That would amount to greedily killing the goose that lays the golden eggs.

    • You wouldn’t consider businesses, bands, authors, non-profit organizations, etc…as “end-users”? I think the statement that “It’s Free and Always Will Be.” is a bit deceiving if they start charging some “users” and not others.

      Just my $.02…though.

      Cheers!

      –Sean

  12. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/Jy3kbfBq via @socmedsean

  13. I love your posts about the hidden nuggets in the legal stuff. Good find.

  14. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/ykFV4cU1 via @socmedsean

  15. We will all see how it turns out in 2 or 3 years.

  16. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/bbWGVr0m via @socmedsean

  17. Very interesting. I am anxious to see if Facebook does start charging developers.

  18. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/mnAQJVDD via @socmedsean

  19. Here’s a question, if they did charge to use it, $5 a month or something would you pay it?

    I wouldn’t.

  20. A most interesting article, Sean. I agree that developers would be the first to get charged a fee. However, since companies Zynga are worth billions, they might see it as an acceptable cost.

  21. “We do not guarantee that the Platform will always be free.” #facebook http://t.co/b5XDf41a

  22. Will Facebook Always Be Free – Probably Not for Everyone. http://t.co/jrzkFyam via @SocMedSean

  23. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/LdGsR7r5 via @socmedsean

  24. Nice Analysis. With quarter to quarter earnings, there will be extra forces on Facebook to drive profitability in a continuous growing cycle.

  25. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/sSX2EEzz via @socmedsean

  26. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/FO0yHqTV via @socmedsean

  27. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/27UhHz5Z via @socmedsean

  28. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/HwXcR3Fd via @socmedsean

  29. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/aABXRn5L via @socmedsean

  30. Thoughts, everyone? Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/VdQBWm3A via @socmedsean

  31. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/fZvMSvFA via @socmedsean

  32. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/UYSFunRI via @socmedsean

  33. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/yLHPpnRP via @socmedsean

  34. I’m so fascinated by Facebook as is everyone else. It’s incredible that they have changed our lives. This article is super. I great point to stir up!

  35. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/rSLNGTSN via @socmedsean

  36. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/MNJ6Fmpk via @socmedsean

  37. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/NI0GekUb (via @summify)

  38. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/E4EgvJVz via @socmedsean

  39. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/56kGMmKY via @socmedsean

  40. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/ykWdlVrD via @socmedsean

  41. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/P2DMKJ1G via @socmedsean @osakasaul

  42. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/4Sn8MxnW

  43. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/POiL5QdV via @socmedsean

  44. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/GlXxoW6v via @socmedsean

  45. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/qGcekHcH via @socmedsean

  46. Sounds like something the lawyers added. I cannot imagine that the developer community would take kindly for paying to develop FB apps. FB could however possibly support an app store for customers to purchase apps but only if they did something really worthwhile and not already provided.

  47. hmmm… interesting. The word “free” is as misused recently as the word “live” TV. A recent advert on TV offered a phone “Free for just £28 per month”.
    Language is more and more being manipulated to make it mean whatever a company wants.
    FB is, slowly, digging it’s own grave, I think.

  48. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/JbVJUbew via @socmedsean

  49. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/3BUkNJZH via @socmedsean

  50. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/WMmj7M2B via @socmedsean

  51. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/ARTTOpJE via @socmedsean

  52. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/LuAz5PMn via @socmedsean

  53. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/0kiaQdkl via @socmedsean

  54. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/tLtPkdE5 via @socmedsean

  55. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/LlwzIew5 via @socmedsean

  56. Will #Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/10ZvbhTW via @socmedsean @candacemountain #SocialMedia

  57. Will Facebook ALWAYS Be Free For Everyone? Their Terms of Use Indicate Otherwise! http://t.co/5E9snuJm

  58. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/ZptVcjOw via @socmedsean

  59. Will Facebook Always Be Free? Probably Not For Everyone! http://t.co/8qWTknpv via @socmedsean

  60. If they charge at some point so be it. I mean there is a sense of entitlement in the internet community that is unfortunate. In fact I think there is an entitlement to an entire generation now. As the saying goes, there’s no such thing as something for nothing. You’re gonna pay for it one way or another right? We’re getting something for free or more so we’re getting it to see a few ads (and more likely ignore them, and/or use adblocking technology) Seems we’re getting a pretty sweet deal.

Speak Your Mind

*

Read previous post:
Once you find the ability to edit the photos in an album, you can also move them to a new album in your Facebook timeline
Updated Social Tip: Organizing Photos In The New Facebook Timeline

Moving photos from one album to another has become a little more difficult in the new Facebook timeline. Here are...

Close